Engineering choices

Eclipse, NetBeans or IntelliJ: Which is the best Java IDE?

Coman Hamilton

Eclipse’s Luna release brought a range of interesting new functions –– but how does the Java IDE stand up to rivals NetBeans and IntelliJ?

For quite some time now, Eclipse has had a thorn in its IDE. With NetBeans and IntelliJ ever at its heels, the Eclipse development environment has been battling to hold sway over the Java community. It’s about time we compared the big three in Java IDEs.

Over on, the German Java community has voted on how Eclipse stands up against the competition. Only 21% of developers believed the Luna release has re-established Eclipse as the best Java IDE in the world. And just over a quarter of participants (26%) would say that Eclipse and its competitors are generally the same, and that each software has its own advantages and disadvantages.

SEE ALSO: IntelliJ vs. NetBeans vs. Eclipse: Which IDE has the best Angular 2 support?

Like in the Windows vs Mac vs Linux debate, it seems that most devs have picked one IDE and are sticking firmly to it. The results make it pretty clear that Eclipse’s Luna hasn’t quite won back the entire Java community.

UPDATE: How about you?

We decided to launch another quick survey to see if users’ preferences have changed.

Which is the best Java IDE?

Loading ... Loading ...

Eclipse: More than an IDE

While IntelliJ IDEA had already long since delivered support for Java 8 (albeit slightly rudimentary), Eclipse struggled to catch up with Java 8 support for its much-awaited Luna release. On top of its new Java 8 features, Luna blinged out with a brand new ‘Dark Theme’ which lets users change the IDE’s background hue – but that’s also nothing that would impress anyone working with NetBeans and IntelliJ IDEA.

The latest update has brought Eclipse up to an impressive 76 individual projects – from software modelling to IoT tools and even runtime projects. Beating that in mind, you might say Eclipse is less of an IDE and more of a technology platform and open source community.

SEE ALSO: The top 10 NetBeans features according to its users

Being slow off the mark to adopt Java 8 functions is relatively insignificant when compared with rough times Eclipse had with the infamous Juno release and its frustrated users. In spite of these troubles, Eclipse makes up for its vices with a vibrant community of developers and a wide range of plugins.

IntelliJ IDEA and NetBeans

In contrast to Eclipse, there’s no doubt about what exactly IntelliJ IDEA does. Since it’s developed by one single company (JetBrains), there’s somewhat less community participation. But that also means that its built-in features are far more cohesive. Eclipse can easily become confusing with its endless plugins built by various community members. IntelliJ IDEA could add a further feather to its cap when Google selected it as the basis for Android Studio – the new development environment for Android.

SEE ALSO: NetBeans 8.1 versus IntelliJ 15

Right in middle, between Eclipse and IntelliJ IDEA, is NetBeans. Previously part of the Sun development environment, NetBeans slipped into the hands of Oracle, but has managed to hold onto its faithful community. NetBeans features platform functions for various extensions, and yet it still provides a clearly framed functionality. The software also has a head start on other IDEs with its JavaFX and HTML5 features.

Each to their own IDE

When it comes to Java IDEs, developers are spoiled for choice. Three free services battling each other to provide the best functions and services – it’s something that other tech communities can only dream of.

Like ninjas vs pirates, deciding on the world’s best Java IDE is purely subjective – it all depends on what you need. A swashbuckling, if sometimes chaotic, collection of plugins or a stealthily integrated functionality?

Coman Hamilton
Coman was Editor of at S&S Media Group. He has a master's degree in cultural studies and has written and edited content for numerous news, tech and culture websites and magazines, as well as several ad agencies.

1 Comment
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Joe Jackson
Joe Jackson
2 years ago

I’m high and i loved reading this. Thanks for the info!