Don't believe the hype

Scala and Dart fail to break into TIOBE Top 50 . . . again

If there are two words that get bandied around the JAXenter and webdev360 and offices more than any others, they’re ‘Scala’ and ‘Dart’ . You can’t fire up InfoQ or DZone these days without seeing the latest release from Typesafe (today’s appearance of Typesafe Stack 2.0 being a case in point) or some snippet of news from the official Dart blog. But, according to the latest TIOBE index, both languages are still struggling to break into the coding mainstream.

In the March 2012 edition of the influential rankings, both Dart and Scala continue to languish in the #50-#100 bracket, a group of languages deemed not popular enough to track properly. They share the spot with such illustrious companions as JScript .NET, REALbasic, JavaFX Script and Go, Google’s own attempt at marrying Python and C++.

The rankings are based on analysing the query “[language] programming” across a number of search engines -- as well as sites such as Wikipedia, YouTube and Amazon -- and have been criticised in the past for the simplicity of their methodology. It certainly seems odd that a pair of languages that get such a lot of media attention (yes, we’re aware that we’re adding to it right now) would fail to translate this PR into real grassroots interest, but it looks like that’s the case.

It’s worth pointing out that research firm Redmonk’s latest rankings, based on “everything from GitHub LOC rankings to LinkedIn group membership data”, are a lot kinder to Scala, placing it behind the cluster of indisputable front-runners (C, Java, PHP, etc.) but firmly in the top end of field. Dart, on the other hand, doesn’t figure at all. We look forward to seeing how things change in the months to come, but for now it looks like a case of ‘don’t believe the hype’.

Louis Goddard

What do you think?

JAX Magazine - 2014 - 06 Exclucively for iPad users JAX Magazine on Android

Comments

Latest opinions